If you are just trying to fix a small mistake, dip a cotton swab in the remover and squeeze out the excess liquid with a tissue. [4] X Research source Then gently erase the mistakes.

This give the makeup remover time to break down the eyeliner so it will come off quickly and easily.

Follow up by washing your face with your usual cleanser.

Sensitive baby wipes can sometimes be used to cleanse your face, but they’re not designed to lift off makeup. Try to stick to wipes that are specifically for makeup removal for the best results. [7] X Research source

Change to a new tip of the wipe for each eye, to prevent transferring anything from eye to eye. Don’t pull or tug the skin too much. This can cause wrinkles. The edges of eyelids are usually neglected during makeup removal. This can be dangerous, as the eyeliner can build up over time and cause some irritation. [8] X Research source

Make sure you are using a trusted brand of highly refined petroleum jelly. It is a byproduct of oil refining and is found in different grades of purity. If it’s not properly purified it can contain harmful toxins. [10] X Research source

Use another, clean cotton swab if you don’t get all your eyeliner off with the first one.

If you get any petroleum jelly in your eyes, rinse with warm water. It may cause your vision to blur temporarily.

Oils are the best option to remove waterproof eyeliner. The oil in waterproof eyeliner repels water, which is why it lasts so long, but also makes it hard to remove.